Value for Money Reviews & Benchmarking

Value for money reviews and procurement benchmarking that stand up to audit

If you are a contracting authority or a publicly funded charity, value for money is not a slogan. It is a duty. Our value for money reviews and procurement benchmarking assignments give you clear answers to simple questions. Are we paying the right price for the quality we receive. Could a different delivery model lower risk and improve outcomes. How do we evidence value for money, social value and sustainability in a way that aligns with the Procurement Act 2023 and your standing orders.

We combine market data, peer comparisons and contract performance analysis with practical recommendations. You choose the engagement style. We can support and guide your team, review and assure your approach, or deliver a full independent review that includes options appraisal and an implementation plan. Our focus is public sector and publicly funded organisations. That includes councils, housing associations and registered providers, NHS bodies, schools and multi academy trusts, colleges, and charities that are classed as contracting authorities.

When a value for money review makes sense

  • A retender is due and you want to enter the market with realistic budgets, an improved specification and a pricing schedule that invites competition
  • Performance is variable and you need to know whether the solution or the price, or both, are out of line with peers
  • Leadership or funders are asking for independent evidence of value for money, social value and environmental impact
  • You are deciding between insourcing, outsourcing or a hybrid model and need a clear comparison of cost, quality and risk
  • A contract is mid term and you want to benchmark commercials and service before agreeing changes or extensions

Scope, deliverables and outcomes

The review is structured so you know what we will do, what you will receive and how it will help you make decisions.

WorkstreamWhat we examineWhat you receiveOutcome
Spend and demandHistoric spend, volumes, sites, routes, shifts, compliance requirements, demand driversCleansed baseline, demand drivers, cost waterfallYou see what really drives cost and where waste hides
Contract and performanceKPIs and SLAs, reporting, abatements, change control, payment certification, disputesPerformance file review and a practical improvement listFaster recovery of weak performance and cleaner audit trail
Market and peersPrices, methods and delivery models used by peers and comparable buyersBenchmark pack with price bands and service modelsYou know what the market will expect and what it will challenge
Model choicesInsource, outsource and hybrid options, collaboration, framework or competition routeOptions appraisal with cost, quality, risk and implementation notesA decision that balances value, control and deliverability
Social value and sustainabilityCurrent commitments and evidence, carbon and resource use, SME and VCSE spendMeasures that matter with simple evidence rulesBenefits that can be delivered and reported without friction
Commercial improvementQuick wins, medium term improvements, price and service leversNegotiation plan, revised schedules, change proposalsMeasurable savings and quality gains with clear next steps

What counts as a benchmark

Benchmarking is more than a price per unit. The best comparisons blend price, method and outcome so you can understand why one offer costs more or less, and what you get in return. We build that comparison for your categories. Typical areas include grounds maintenance, facilities management, cleaning, waste, catering, transport and fleet, IT managed services, security, professional services, energy and utilities, FF&E and building compliance.

DimensionHow we compareData sourcesTypical result
PriceUnit rates, composite rates and total cost of ownershipMarket submissions, framework schedules, peer data where shareableRealistic budget bands and a view of where you sit today
MethodCrew mix, route design, shift patterns, tech use, self delivery vs subcontractSite surveys, mobilisation plans, supplier interviewsPractical options that explain cost and quality differences
OutcomeFirst time fix, satisfaction, safety, complaints, rework, availabilityKPI dashboards, audits, site checks, stakeholder interviewsClear links between what you buy and what residents or users experience
RiskSingle points of failure, supplier concentration, change control, exit readinessContract and file review, spend analysis, risk workshopsRisk heat map and the few actions that change it
Social value and sustainabilityLocal jobs and apprentices, SME spend, waste diversion, carbon intensityHR and payroll extracts, invoices, telematics, meter readsLow effort measures and a credible plan to improve them

Insourced, outsourced or hybrid

We often find that the best model depends on the service and the local context. Insourcing can work well where service quality relies on local knowledge and on site supervision. Outsourcing can deliver speed, coverage and innovation where the market is deep and the specification is tight. A hybrid model can hold core capability while buying specialist capacity flexibly. We set out the real differences between the models, including overheads, management cost, training and supervision requirements, systems and tooling, and exit complexity. We then test them against your aims and constraints.

What you can expect from the options appraisal

  • A five year view of cost that includes one off and recurring items
  • A side by side comparison of quality, resilience and control
  • Clear notes on legal routes and procurement choices such as open competition, framework call off and dynamic markets
  • Implementation steps, resource needs and a realistic timetable

Preparing for a retender

A strong competition starts with a clean baseline and a fair specification. We help you move from internal knowledge to a market ready pack. That includes right sized lots, sensible service boundaries and a pricing schedule that cuts out ambiguity. We use pre market engagement to test and refine the approach without shaping it for one supplier. We then align the evaluation model so it rewards the outcomes you want, not just a low price on day one.

Retender readiness checklist

  • Updated specification with measurable outputs and clear exceptions
  • Pricing schedule that aligns with how delivery is managed and evidenced
  • Evaluation plan with model answers, weightings and a moderation guide
  • Social value and sustainability questions that match your local plan and can be evidenced later
  • Contract schedules tuned for performance reporting, payment certification, change control and exit

Continuous value for money during delivery

Winning a better deal is half the work. Keeping value during delivery is the other half. We wire your value for money intentions into contract management so the gains show up month by month. That includes a small set of KPIs and SLAs that really matter, a dashboard that links price to performance, and payment certification rules that resist drift. We track social value and sustainability alongside quality and cost. If a change will save money or improve outcomes, we run change control in a way that preserves scope clarity and budget control.

Evidence that convinces boards and funders

Evidence should be simple, repeatable and rooted in data you already hold. We start with what you can produce today. We then add small improvements that improve reliability and reduce effort. We do not encourage large reporting builds unless they are necessary. Where you must publish data or KPIs, we align the dashboard so you can meet publication duties without creating a second set of numbers.

Typical results

Every organisation is different, but the pattern is familiar. Clean baselines reduce noise. Clear specifications attract better bids. Aligned measures keep suppliers focused. Payment certification with tested evidence brings predictability to spend. The combination often produces net savings and better outcomes within a year, with larger structural improvements following through reprocurement or model changes.

A straightforward process and timeline

You get speed without cutting corners. The cadence below suits most buyers and can be adjusted to fit your governance.

PhaseTimeframeWhat happensDeliverables
DiagnosticWeeks 1 to 3Data load, interviews, site checks, contract file reviewBaseline report, risk log, early findings
Deep diveWeeks 4 to 8Benchmarking, market testing, performance analysis, model testingBenchmark pack, options appraisal draft
DecisionsWeeks 9 to 10Workshops with budget holders and service leadsOptions appraisal final, decision record
Delivery planWeeks 11 to 12Retender prep or contract improvement plan, negotiation playbookReady to run pack and a dated action plan

What you receive

  • Value for money report in plain English, with a short executive summary and focused recommendations
  • Benchmark pack that shows price, method and outcome bands for your category and context
  • Options appraisal that compares insourcing, outsourcing and hybrid models with cost, quality and risk
  • Retender or renegotiation materials such as refined specifications, pricing schedules and evaluation notes
  • A compact dashboard template with KPI, SLA, social value and sustainability measures that can be evidenced
  • Implementation support where needed, from supplier engagement to evaluation moderation and change control

Pricing and engagement

We can run a fixed price review with a clear scope and timetable. For larger or multi category reviews we can set a capped fee with stage gates, or call off support through a rate card. You keep budget control. We provide a named lead and a small team so momentum is steady and stakeholders know who to contact.

Social value and sustainability as part of value for money

Value for money includes more than price and service. It includes public benefit. We select a small set of social value and sustainability measures that match your local plan, can be delivered by the category and can be evidenced without burden. We then link them to the review and any subsequent retender. That way the same measures carry through from decision to delivery.

ThemeMeasureEvidenceHow it links to value
Local jobs and skillsApprentice weeks and local hiresPayroll extracts and training logsBuilds capacity and resilience in the local labour market
SME and VCSE participationPercent of spend with local SMEs and VCSEsInvoice data and supplier listsKeeps spend in the local economy and shortens supply chains
Carbon and wasteFleet fuel, energy use, waste diversionTelematics, meter reads and waste ticketsReduces operating costs and environmental impact
Community benefitHours delivered or outcomes achievedRegisters and beneficiary feedbackAligns contractor activity to local priorities

Where benchmarks create the biggest gains

Some categories respond very well to method and outcome based benchmarking. Examples include:

  • Grounds maintenance with route design, crew mix and seasonal plans that match the estate
  • Facilities management where helpdesk data and response patterns reveal workload truths
  • Cleaning and janitorial where specification clarity and outcome testing improve both quality and price
  • Waste and recycling where container strategy, lift frequency and contamination control drive cost
  • Transport and fleet where telematics and duty cycles inform route redesign and asset choice
  • Professional services where deliverables and acceptance criteria remove scope drift
  • Energy and utilities where flexible procurement must be matched with demand reduction to show net benefit

Frequently asked questions

Yes. We can build robust comparisons using market data, framework schedules and peer information where shareable. If you later choose to retender, the work carries forward.

A light annual check is sensible for large contracts. A full review is best before a retender or a major change.

Then the review will show it. We will still list improvements to tighten performance, evidence and cost control.

 Yes. We cost internal structures and overheads honestly, test market delivery models and show a side by side picture of cost, quality, risk and implementation effort.

 Yes. We refine specifications and pricing schedules, draft evaluation notes and run pre market engagement so the competition is attractive and fair.

 Yes. We can set a short performance recovery plan, tune KPIs and SLAs, tighten certification and run targeted changes that improve service and cost control.

Use the free procurement tools

Use Buying adviser to explore your buying question, Find a framework to investigate framework options, or Supplier engagement to plan how you approach the market. Create a free account to access the three tools, or sign in to continue.

Free membership also includes procurement quizzes by level, country and topic.

New to My Desk? Read the guides to the free tools.

Need support with the procurement itself? Speak to our procurement team. Consultancy is quoted separately.

Related Resources

Contract management services for contracting authorities and publicly funded charities. Outsourced contract management, independent contract administration, supplier performance, social value and sustainability reporting, change control and value for money.
Bespoke procurement recruitment delivered around your procurement and contract management needs. Permanent, interim and executive search for UK public, third sector and private organisations, with technical assessment, fast shortlists and transparent fees.
Practical, bespoke procurement training delivered around your procurement and contract management needs. Built for UK public and third sector teams to strengthen compliance, value for money, social value delivery and supplier performance from planning to contract close.

Ready to talk

If you need support with a live procurement, a contract that needs attention or a value for money review, we can help.

Call 01204 238 046
Email hello@thorntonandlowe.com

Request a free consultation and we will agree the next step.

Scroll to Top